22
My buddy from college in Australia told me their 'hate speech' laws would stop online fights. I thought he was nuts.
We were talking about a big online fight over a political cartoon, and he said their laws meant you could get fined for posting stuff that might offend a group. I told him that was just a way to shut people up and that free speech means dealing with ugly opinions. He said it actually made discussions calmer because people had to think before they posted. I didn't buy it, thinking it was just government overreach. But after seeing how some of our own online spaces have turned into pure rage zones where no real talk happens, I'm starting to see his point. It's a tough spot, because I still don't like the idea of a government deciding what's too offensive. Has anyone else had a chat with someone from a country with really strict speech rules that made you rethink things?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
miller.avery2mo ago
Funny enough, the plumbing code has a lot of rules that seem annoying until you realize they stop people's basements from flooding. Maybe some speech rules are like that, a basic safety thing for the public square. The trick is who writes the code and if they ever update it for new problems.
6
blair_allen2mo ago
Honestly that's the real issue, who gets to be the plumber and how often they check the pipes.
3
hayden58728d ago
Who writes the code and if they ever update it" yeah that's the thing right there. My buddy worked for this small town that had this old plumbing code from like 1982 that said you could use these specific iron pipes for everything. Fast forward to 2021, the town had this huge water main break that flooded like 6 blocks because those pipes had corroded and nobody checked them in decades. Turns out the guy who wrote that code was some retired plumber who was friends with the iron pipe salesman in the 80s. So you got these rules that were maybe fine once but nobody ever looked at them again, and then everyone's basement is full of muddy water because of it. I feel like speech rules might work the same way, they make sense for the problems they were made for but the world changes faster than the rulebook does.
2