23
Book club fallout over a single character's choice
Last month at our meeting in the library basement, we spent an hour arguing about whether a character in 'The Great Alone' should have left Alaska. One member said it was cowardly, another said it was survival. I left feeling like nobody really heard each other, just pushed their own ideas. Has anyone else had a book club debate turn personal like that?
2 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In2 Comments
riverhill8d ago
I get what you're saying but I actually disagree that a lighter book is the answer. The whole point of a book club is to dig into stuff that makes people uncomfortable, even if it gets a little heated. Honestly those debates about character choices ARE about personal values and that's what makes them interesting. If everyone just nods along about a fluffy beach read you might as well be talking about the weather. I'd rather have a real argument that leaves me thinking than another polite conversation where nobody says anything that matters. The key is just keeping it respectful when it gets passionate, not avoiding the hard stuff entirely.
8
dakota_singh398d ago
Oh man, I feel your pain on this one. My old book club almost fell apart over a similar thing - someone got super defensive about a character's choices and then it just turned into a whole thing about personal values instead of the book. Best advice I got was to start the next meeting by saying "okay, let's all agree that we can talk about what we hated or loved without it meaning something about our own life choices." It sounds cheesy but it actually works if you laugh about it first. Also maybe pick a lighter book next time, something where nobody has to make serious life decisions.
1