Loading…
10
The day our book talk turned into a shouting match
We read a book with a confusing plot. Half the group loved the mystery, half found it annoying. In the debate, I saw that people were not even talking about the same things. It hit me that we needed a better way to frame our talks. Now, I start with clear questions for each meeting. This idea came from my pottery class, where we critique each other's work. Having structure stops fights and helps us learn.
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
scott.abby7mo ago
Clear questions are a game changer! We use a 'three things' rule in my group: everyone shares one thing they loved, one thing they hated, and one question. It keeps things focused and fun!
7
the_kevin7mo ago
Scott.abby, that "one thing they hated" part of your rule might be where the problem slips back in. Hated is such a final word, you know? It shuts down talk instead of opening it up. Why not say "one thing that confused you" or "one part that fell flat"? It points to the book, not the person who liked it. Didn't we all see how shouting starts when people get personal? A little change like that keeps your structure but cuts the chance for a fight.
4