I finally saw why my local art supply store hides the 'Mapplethorpe' books

Last month I was in Portland at this little shop that sells prints and photography books. I asked for a Mapplethorpe collection behind the counter, and the owner just stared at me. He said, "We don't keep those out front, folks complain." I thought he was being dramatic. But then he showed me the cover, and I realized I'd never actually looked at the whole book, just the famous flower shots online. The full version has stuff that would make my uncle's head spin. It hit me that I'd been treating censorship as this abstract thing, but here it was, just a guy trying to keep his business from getting yelled at. Does anyone else have a moment where a small shop owner explained a ban or restriction in a way that made you rethink your whole stance? What was the item?

1 comments

1 Comment

the_mary18d agoMost Upvoted

Two summers ago I watched a comic shop owner in Tucson pull a graphic novel off the shelf and flip to a page with a dead dog in it, then explain that he had to keep it behind the counter because parents would flip if their kids saw it. That one moment made me realize the line between protecting kids and hiding art is way blurrier than I thought. He wasn't some moral crusader, he was just tired of refund arguments. The weird part is that he showed me the scene and it was honestly more sad than shocking. But I get why he did it. Sometimes the small shop owner is just the middleman between a bookstore's catalog and a Karen's complaint, and that position forces them to make calls that feel wrong until you see the actual customer.