Vent: I tried to play detective on a 1987 cold case in Ohio and ended up with a pizza guy mad at me
So a few weeks back I got way too deep into this 1987 missing persons case out of Lima, Ohio, and I thought I cracked it with a theory about a gas station receipt. I called the local historical society to confirm a detail and the guy on the phone thought I was a reporter and gave me a whole spiel about how they get 20 calls a week from armchair sleuths. Then I emailed a tip to the county sheriff's office with my big theory, and 3 days later a deputy called back to politely tell me the receipt was already logged in the file back in 1988 and the case was still open but nothing new. I felt like a total clown. The funny part is my wife asked who I was on the phone with for 40 minutes and I had to admit it was a bored deputy in Allen County explaining how evidence logs work. Lesson learned: the internet makes every old case feel solvable until you actually talk to someone with the file. Has anyone here ever sent a tip to a police dept on an old case and actually got a real answer back?