My writing group got into a 45 minute fight over whether prompts should be one sentence or a whole paragraph
Last Tuesday at our library meetup in Boise, a lady named Carol passed out these one line prompts like 'write about a locked door' while another guy handed out a full page setup about a lighthouse keeper in 1923. Half the table said the short ones force you to build the world yourself and the long ones just hand you the story, and the other half said a bare prompt gives you nothing to grab onto so you sit there for 20 minutes. Which side are you on, and does it change if it's for a group versus writing alone?
Carol's one line prompts would kill me, I'd stare at "write about a locked door" for 30 minutes then write about my own front door being stuck. Honestly I need the lighthouse guy's paragraph, give me some people and a year and I'm off. In a group though I get why short wins, nobody wants to hear 6 versions of the same 1923 lighthouse.