Shoutout to the 10 minute timer that showed me my prompts were solving the story for the writer
So I've been writing prompt posts on a little forum for about a year and a half, and last Tuesday I finally figured out what I was doing wrong the whole time. A guy named Marcus replied to one of my prompts about a character finding a letter in an old coat and he said, quote, "this one already knows the ending, so there's nothing for me to write." I sat there for a bit and then read through my last forty prompts and realized almost every single one told the writer what the twist was, or what the character was feeling, or how it should end. I was basically handing people a finished sandwich and calling it a recipe. So I started setting a 10 minute timer and writing prompts with a person, a problem, and one weird detail, then cutting anything that explained the feeling or hinted at the answer. The first batch felt scary because it looked like I'd written way less, but the replies got longer and people started posting three versions of the same prompt. Now I keep a sticky note on my monitor that just says "leave the door open" and it catches me before I ruin a good idea. If you write prompts, go back and read your last ten and count how many give away the ending, then tell me if you got the same sinking feeling I did.