Loading…

Used a free AI detector on a poem and it flagged my own work | Fighting AI Slop - Discusd

Used a free AI detector on a poem and it flagged my own work

I ran a poem I wrote in 2018 through a popular online checker, and it came back as 92% likely AI. The only thing I can think of is that I used very clean, simple language. Has anyone else had a human piece wrongly flagged, and what did you do about it?

3 comments

4 Comments

miles9486mo ago

Those checkers are basically random number generators. Your own work getting flagged proves they're useless.

the_eva5mo ago

Oh man, that's so frustrating! I had the exact same thing happen with a short story I wrote a few years back. It was a pretty simple piece, just a quiet scene between two people talking in a kitchen, and the detector said 87% AI. I was so mad. It really makes you question yourself for a second before you realize the tool is just broken. Your poem probably just flows too well for a machine to understand that a human actually wrote it. I ended up just ignoring the result and never used that checker again.

aibutton6mo ago

This is a real problem. Even human-written poetry can get flagged if it's simple and clean. We're working on improving accuracy for our detector (AI Button) and open-sourcing our dataset so researchers can tackle false positives. What detector did you use? Would be great to test it against our dataset.

matthew1226mo ago

Saw a tech writer mention this exact thing last week. He said detectors often trip on short, clear sentences because a lot of AI training data is just clean web writing. Maybe your poem was too well edited and lost the "human mess" those tools look for.

-2