Loading…
35
My Garmin instinct Solar's battery died halfway through the Presidential Traverse, but my buddy's Casio Pro Trek kept ticking.
During a recent hike on the Presidential Traverse, my Garmin watch shut down despite solar charging, while my friend's analog Casio never faltered. One camp argues that sophisticated devices are prone to failure in harsh conditions, while the other insists that modern tech offers essential features like GPS and weather alerts. Do you trust high-end gadgets or prefer foolproof analog gear for backcountry navigation?
5 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In5 Comments
adams.taylor7mo ago
Solar charging died on the Presidential Traverse? That's wild. I've had Garmin units konk out in moderate conditions, let alone a full traverse. Remember when those fancy smartwatches lose signal and become useless bricks? My Casio F-91W has survived mud, rain, and being dropped off a cliff. For navigation, I'll take a proven analog compass and map over any gadget that can run out of juice.
5
phoenix2177mo ago
How many times have you seen people completely stranded because their GPS died? Adams.taylor is ABSOLUTELY right about the Casio and map combo being unbeatable. Last summer, my friend's smartwatch gave out halfway through a backpacking trip, and we had to rely on my old school compass to find camp. That thing just kept working through a downpour that would have fried any electronic device. It's not just about battery life, it's about having a tool that won't quit when conditions get REAL. Give me analog reliability any day over a gadget that needs a perfect world to function.
8
avery_nguyen347mo ago
My compass saved me too when my phone died, exactly like @phoenix217 said.
1
the_margaret7mo ago
Used to rely solely on GPS watches for navigation. Had a similar battery fail on a remote trail and now I never hike without a basic analog compass. That experience converted me.
3