Hey, I've been through this! My BYOC kit was great for basics, but shimmer introduced so much noise. Ended up investing in a Strymon for clean algorithms, totally worth it.
It's cool gear for sure, but most audiences wouldn't notice a little noise in a live mix. Chasing that last 5% of pristine sound sometimes feels more like an engineer's hobby than a musician's need. Those algorithms are amazing, but the noise argument gets overblown for bedroom producers. In a band context, that subtle artifact is totally buried anyway.